Is Your Storage Unit Worth the Cost? When to Stop Paying for Storage
What if you're paying more to store your belongings than those belongings are actually worth?
A listener recently sent Juliet and me a question that really made me think.
When she downsized her home, she rented a storage unit for $189 a month. The plan was to keep it for a few months while she figured out what to do with the extra furniture and belongings.
Well, a few months turned into more than two years.
She's now paid $5,103 in storage fees.
And here's the part that caught my attention. If she sold everything inside that unit, she estimates she'd get about $800.
That's a tough financial reality.
The harder part? Some of those belongings belonged to her mother.
So this isn't just about money. It's about memories, family, and the difficulty of letting things go.
When Your Storage Unit Costs More Than Your Stuff
Let's look at the numbers.
At $189 a month, she's paying $2,268 every year to keep those belongings in storage.
Over 27 months, that's $5,103.
Compare that with the estimated $800 resale value of everything inside.
She's already paid more than six times the estimated resale value just to keep those possessions.
Now, that doesn't mean those belongings have no value.
There's a difference between what something is worth financially and what it means to you emotionally.
I understand wanting to hold onto something that belonged to someone you love.
Still, every month she waits costs another $189.
And that brings us to the question I think matters most.
Is Keeping That Storage Unit Worth Another $189?
Here's the test I suggested during our conversation.
Would you willingly pay another $189 this month to keep what's inside that unit?
Forget what you paid for those belongings years ago.
Forget what you might do with them someday.
Ask yourself whether keeping them today is worth the ongoing expense.
Sometimes we convince ourselves that we're making a decision by waiting.
The truth is, waiting is a decision, too. And in this case, it comes with a monthly bill.
How to Stop Paying for Storage Without Losing the Memories
Juliet brought up an idea I really liked.
What if you could preserve the memories without keeping every physical object?
You might photograph sentimental items, scan old documents, or create a smaller collection of the things that mean the most to you.
You don't have to keep an entire storage unit to remember someone you love.
Here's how I'd approach it.
1. Set a Deadline
Pick a realistic date to empty and close the storage unit.
Put it on your calendar and commit to it.
Without a deadline, it's too easy to keep telling yourself you'll handle it next month.
2. Sort Everything Into Four Categories
Go through your belongings and decide what to keep, sell, donate, or discard.
You don't have to make every difficult decision in one afternoon.
Make an initial pass, then return to reconsider the items you're unsure about.
3. Set a Limit on What You'll Keep
Juliet suggested choosing a specific number of boxes.
I think that's a great idea.
Maybe you decide to keep two large storage totes that fit inside your home.
Once they're full, you have to make choices about which items matter most.
4. Give the Rest a New Purpose
Some belongings might be worth selling.
Others could be donated to people who will actually use them.
The important thing is to stop paying indefinitely for things you no longer need.
5. Close the Unit and Redirect the Money
Once you've emptied the unit, follow the facility's move-out requirements and confirm the rental is canceled.
At $189 a month, that's $2,268 over the next 12 months that could go toward emergency savings, debt repayment, or another financial goal.
That's a meaningful amount of money.
Keeping the Memories Doesn't Mean Keeping Everything
I don't think this listener's biggest problem is understanding the math.
She already knows the storage unit is expensive.
The challenge is making a decision that feels emotionally difficult.
And I get that.
There are things in life that matter far more than their resale value.
Still, holding onto a memory doesn't always mean paying rent to keep every physical reminder.
Keep what matters. Let go of what doesn't. And stop paying for decisions you've been putting off.
Your Money Move This Week
If you're renting a storage unit, take 15 minutes and calculate what you've spent over the past year.
Then ask yourself whether that expense is still helping you accomplish something meaningful.
Maybe keeping the unit makes sense for your situation.
Or maybe it's time to make a plan to close it.
Either way, I want you to make that decision intentionally.
NEW: Join Me for Free Office Hours
Starting Tuesday, December 1, at 7:00 PM Eastern, I'll be hosting free Office Hours every two weeks through our Skool community.
It's a relaxed, 30-minute Google Meet where you can bring your personal finance questions, share a financial win, or simply listen and learn.
No preset topic. No sales pitch. Just a chance to connect and talk about money.
Join our free community and get access to Office Hours
Select Skool Community on the Connect page to get started.
And remember, Juliet and I are here to help you become more confident with your financial decisions.